Timothy Card with County Executive PJ Wendel

Chautauqua County Executive PJ Wendel has appointed Timothy Card as the new Director of the Chautauqua County Department of Public Facilities (DPF).

Card will begin his new position on September 6, 2022. He replaces former director Brad Bentley, who resigned from the position in December 2021.

Card has worked for the Town of Harmony since 1990, serving for six years as a motor equipment operator before becoming the highway superintendent in 1996. Prior to his position with the town, he worked at Maplevale Farms, Inc. as a forklift operator and truck driver.

Card earned his degree in Construction and Heavy Equipment at the Hewes Center at Erie 2-Chautauqua-Cattaraugus BOCES in Ashville. He graduated from Panama Central School and he currently lives in Ashville.

The Chautauqua County Sheriff’s Office says they received a report of a plane down on Baker Street Extension just after 11:00 p.m..

The pilot, 63-year old Lawrence Zupon of Bentleyville, Ohio, had been conducting training exercises when the plane lost power, causing the plane to crash into a wooded area. Zupon and passenger, 25-year old Daniel Rossi of Mayfield Heights, Ohio were able to escape the wreckage. They were treated at the scene before being sent to Hamot Medical Center in Erie for further treatment.

The accident remains under investigation by the Sheriff’s Office and the Federal Aviation Administration.

The Chautauqua County Sheriff’s Office along with the Panama fire department responded just before midnight Saturday to an address on Washington Street in Harmony for a report of an ATV into a creek with a person missing in the water.

Deputies determined multiple people had been riding the ATV when the driver failed to see a creek ahead and overturned the vehicle in the creek. The driver of the ATV had minor injuries but a passenger, 58-year old Donna Phelps of Dothan, Alabama, had gone missing in the water.

Deputies and fire personnel found Phelps in the water a distance from the overturned ATV. They tried to resuscitate her but she was pronounced dead at UPMC Chautauqua.

The incident remains under investigation by the Chautauqua County Sheriff’s Office.

An official from the Town of Harmony (shown in red) says the listing of a hate group operating out of the town by the Southern Poverty Law Center is false, and it was irresponsible of WRFA to carry the story.

PANAMA, NY – Contrary to a recent report from the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC), there is not a KKK-affiliated group operating out of Chautauqua County.

That’s according to an official from the Town of Harmony, who contacted WRFA this week and took issue with a story WRFA ran on Feb. 22, regarding a report from SPLC that identified Panama, NY on its 2016 Hate Map as one of the headquarters for the Church of the National Knights of the Ku Klux Klan.

The town official, who said they’d prefer not to have their name included as part of this report, told WRFA community leaders are aware of just one individual in the area who’s claimed himself as being the so-called leader of a KKK-affiliated group, adding that they’ve been aware of this individual for the past few years.

However, the Harmony official takes issue with the SPLC’s claim that this individual is the actual head of any kind of KKK-affiliated group – organized or otherwise – adding that this so-called leader is simply someone who has access to the Internet and has made the claims online, but that doesn’t mean there is any substantive truth to them. As a result, he said the SPLC’s claim that a KKK-affiliated group is operating in Panama is flat-out false.

The town official went on to say the SPLC should have done proper due diligence in researching the matter, before placing the so-called group on the Hate Map, and that just because someone goes on the Internet and claims to be the head of a group or organization, doesn’t make it true.

The town official also expressed his disappointment with WRFA, saying we were irresponsible to report the story without first discussing the matter further with elected officials in the town of Harmony or village of Panama.

In our initial report, SPLC senior fellow Mark Potok told us, “The fact that it’s leader is headquartered in Panama doesn’t necessarily mean at all that he carries out any activities – street rallies or leafleting or anything like that there,” Potok explained. “We find as a general matter that very often leaders do not really engage in Klan activities in their hometown, basically because it would make life miserable for them. So in his case, I’m not sure where they’ve been active – other than they are a real group and they exist on the ground.”

The complete interview with Potok is also available on our website.

In researching the initial story, WRFA did locate on social media the individual identified by Potok as being the head of the local group, and did verify that he lived in the area and claimed to be the head of a KKK group. This individual also publicly posted content that was consistent with what would be affiliated with the KKK or other white supremacy groups and their sentiments. WRFA also spoke with one community official – who also didn’t want their name included in our initial story. That person said they wanted to assure the public that Panama and the surrounding area is tolerant and inclusive, and that because someone with alleged ties to a hate group is living in the area is in no way a reflection of the entire community.

The Southern Poverty Law Center was founded in 1971 as an American nonprofit legal advocacy organization specializing in civil rights and public interest litigation. Since at least 1999, the organization has published an annual Hate Map, outlining the location of hate groups operating within the United States that have beliefs or practices that attack or malign an entire class of people, typically for their immutable characteristics. SPLC has been used as a media source for tracking and reporting on hate groups across the country, including such notable news sources as ABC News, Fox News, NPR, and the BBC. 

A portion of the 2016 Hate Map, released by the Southern Poverty Law Center, shows seven ‘Hate Groups’ operating in Western New York, including one in Chautauqua County identified as the Church of the National Knights of the Ku Klux Klan.

NOTE: Since this story initially ran on Feb. 22, 2017, a subsequent followup has been posted by WRFA.

– – – – – – – – – –

MONTGOMERY, ALA. – The number of hate groups in the United States rose for a second year in a row in 2016.

That’s according to a report released earlier this month by the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC), which not only tracks the number of hate groups in the country, but also provides an interactive “Hate Map” that shows where the headquarters for the groups are located.

SPLC identified 917 hate groups in operation across the country– up from 892 in 2015.  The SPLC defines hate groups as those that “… have beliefs or practices that attack or malign an entire class of people, typically for their immutable characteristics.”

Seven of those groups are headquartered in Western New York and, for the first time since the organization began tracking data, one group is listed as being headquartered in Chautauqua County.

According to SPLC, the Church of the National Knights of the Ku Klux Klan has a headquarters in the Town of Harmony near Panama.

SPLC senior fellow and editor of the Intelligence Report Mark Potok tells WRFA that this group is one of several that are an offshoot of the original KKK from the 1860s, although it’s been in decline for the past few decades.

“The church is an organization that started quite a long time ago in 1960. It was based then as a confederation of southern Klans formed to battle back against the civil rights movement,” Potok explained, adding that during its heyday, the group was responsible for coordinating more than 1000 simultaneous church burnings across the south. “The church is now much smaller than it used to be. It’s a mere four chapters and are headquartered in Panama, NY. They’ve also got chapters in Kentucky, Mississippi, and North Carolina.”

Potok also says that the SPLC came to be aware of the headquarters in Panama through internet activity.

“They’ve announced themselves so it wasn’t any great piece of detective work to find them, and that’s true of most Klan groups. There are a few that really seek to remain secret but I would say the large majority of Klan groups in the United States are highly interested in publicity – they like getting public attention,” Potok said, adding, “They’ve got a webpage and so on where  they list their chapters and that kind of thing.”

And Potok also tells WRFA that while the Church of the National Knights of the KKK is headquartered in the county, it doesn’t mean it is active in the county.

“The fact that it’s leader is headquartered in Panama doesn’t necessarily mean at all that he carries out any activities – street rallies or leafleting or anything like that there,” Potok explained. “We find as a general matter that very often Klan leaders do not really engage in Klan activities in their home town, basically because it would make life miserable for them. So in his case, I’m not sure where they’ve been active – other than they are a real group and they exist on the ground.”

Potok says that purpose of the annual Hate Map is to not draw attention to the groups, but to educate and raise awareness for the general public.

“The reality is that many people in our country are quite shocked to learn that there is a Klan group in the town next door, or a neo-Nazi organization in the county next to your own,” Potok said. “So that’s really our purpose is to educate the public about these groups – the fact that they have not simply disappeared, as many people think they did in the 1960s, and that in fact they’ve been growing in recent years.”

According to the SPLC, the growth in hate groups in the country in 2016 has been accompanied by a rash of crimes targeting Muslims, including an arson that destroyed a mosque in Victoria, Texas, just hours after the Trump administration announced an executive order suspending travel from some predominantly Muslim countries. The latest FBI statistics show that hate crimes against Muslims grew by 67 percent in 2015, the year in which Trump launched his campaign.

“2016 was an unprecedented year for hate,” Potok said in the report at the SPLC website. “The country saw a resurgence of white nationalism that imperils the racial progress we’ve made, along with the rise of a president whose policies reflect the values of white nationalists. In Steve Bannon, these extremists think they finally have an ally who has the president’s ear.”

SPLC was founded in 1971 is an American nonprofit legal advocacy organization specializing in civil rights and public interest litigation. The organization’s identifications and listings of hate groups have been the subject of controversy, with critics arguing it has taken an incautious approach to assigning the label of “hate group.”

WRFA will have a complete interview with Potok during our upcoming Community Matters program, which airs at 5 p.m. Thursday, Feb. 23.

Meanwhile, officials in Panama and Harmony are aware of the SPLC listing. One official told WRFA they want to assure the public that Panama and the surrounding area is tolerant and inclusive, and that because someone with ties to a hate group is living in the area in no way means it’s a reflection of the entire community.